Brand New Sole Society "So-Natasha" Booties for $45 obo

I usually wear a 5 for Sole Society but somehow it fits a bit too tightly. It is sold for $62.97 online but it was final sale so I cannot return it. I am asking for $45 obo.

http://www.solesociety.com/natasha-washed-navy.html

Message me if you are interested in even just trying them on to see if they will fit!